They say that diamonds are a girls best friend. So how do you make sure to pick one that’s a keeper? Whether you’re shopping for yourself or someone special, choosing between lab-grown and natural diamonds isn’t a decision to take lightly. From cost to sparkle, this quick guide will help you weigh up what matters most in your buying decision.
What’s the Difference Between Lab-Grown and Natural Diamonds?
The main difference between synthetic diamonds vs natural diamonds is their origin. Natural diamonds take billions of years to form underground, whereas lab-grown diamonds are created in a lab in just a few weeks. Both are 100% real diamonds formed from carbon, with the same crystal structure, brilliance, and hardness.
Synthetic diamonds aren’t to be confused with imitation jewels, like cubic zirconia. CZ may be clear and sparkly, but it’s made of an entirely different substance and is easy for a professional to tell apart. Meanwhile, lab diamonds are identical to diamonds to the naked eye, even to most jewellers. Only specialised equipment can tell them apart.
Lab-Grown Diamonds: Pros, Cons & Price
One of the biggest benefits of lab-grown diamonds is their price. For the same size and cut, you can expect to pay about 35% less for a synthetic diamond vs a natural one. That means you can choose a larger or higher-quality lab-grown stone for the same budget.
Because they’re produced in controlled environments, lab-grown diamonds usually come with excellent clarity and colour grades. If you’re focused on size, sparkle, or value for money, they’re an attractive option.
Want help understanding diamond clarity, colour, and cut? Read Choosing A Diamond With A Guide To The 4Cs.
Why Natural Diamonds Are Still in Demand
For many people, a natural diamond is still the traditional choice. There’s a legacy factor to gifting or proposing with a stone formed over millennia. It’s timeless, irreplaceable, and has a sense of rarity you can’t get from something produced en masse in a lab environment.
Some buyers feel natural diamonds hold more long-term value and better lend themselves to heirloom pieces. Due to their rarity and reputation in the luxury jewellery market, natural diamonds do command a higher resale value, but trends may shift as lab-grown diamonds become more accepted.
Planning on proposing? Be sure to read 5 Tips for Choosing an Engagement Ring.
Sustainability & Ethics: Which Option Aligns with Your Values?
No article discussing this topic would be complete without addressing the elephant in the room. ‘Blood diamonds’ play a big part in some people’s opposition to traditional stones. The negative impact of unethical diamond mining is a real issue, and one that makes lab-grown diamonds often seem a more environmentally friendly choice. But the industry is nuanced, and many natural diamonds today are sourced ethically and responsibly from certified suppliers.
If ethical sourcing is important to you, both options can meet that standard, it just depends on the jeweller and the source. At Michael Spencer, all our natural diamonds are ethically sourced from reputable suppliers. Explore our wedding and engagement rings.
So, Which Should You Choose?
There’s no right or wrong answer, only what’s right for you or your partner. Here’s a quick way to think about it:
Choose Lab-Grown If You Want… | Choose Natural If You Want… |
|
|
Still unsure? Pop in and see us, we’ll show you both, answer your questions, and help you choose the diamond that feels just right.